HOME
DV NEWS
SERVICE ARCHIVE SUBMISSIONS/CONTACT ABOUT DV
Do
You Want to Know Who the
Americans
Running Iraq Really Are?
by
Jan Oberg
May
21, 2003
They
are people with a background in the far-right of the Republican Party, the
Israel lobby, Perle and Wolfowitz henchmen, central to the war on terror, to
the Homeland Defence authorities, to anti-ABM and pro-Ballistic Missile Defence
(Star Wars), close to conservative think tanks, affiliated with mercenary
companies, the military-industrial complex (MIC) and CIA. They are former
"stabilisers" in Bosnia and Kosovo, and Marine Corps-people (many in
Vietnam); they are private consulting firm executives affiliated with the inner
circles of power in Washington. And, of course, several are associated with the
oil industry, the computer industry as well as the media and public relations
industry. With a few exceptions they are Pentagon and not State Department people,
they are generals and technocrats.
Less
than a handful have any prior experience in Iraq or in nation-building,
conflict-resolution, reconciliation, post-war trauma healing, civil society
empowerment and other quite relevant matters. In short, they are perfectly fit
to "do" Iraq for the US and totally unsuitable for the Iraqis. They
are not accountable to anyone, except President Bush and Secretary of Defence
Donald Rumsfeld. Their operations and decisions are not transparent to the
world community or any world organisation.
The
Bush regime is setting up a basically military administration in Iraq. The
disputes and the infighting are coming out in the open, as reported by the
Washington Post on May 4. General Jay Garner and Ambassador Bremer and a team
of some 300 retired military men, diplomats and functionaries from numerous US government
agencies have been recruited by the Bush regime, and especially by the
Pentagon, to administer postwar Iraq. None of them are coming to Iraq as a
result of democratic processes. They have been appointed in ambiguous ways to
supposedly quick-fix something they call democracy among 24 million Iraqis.
It's the largest nation-building project in modern times. It is supposed to
create an interim government by mid-May.
Why
is their presence in Iraq causing so little debate, not to speak of outrage? There
are basically four reasons: 1) because they are Americans and the US is a
country few dare investigate and question; 2) because the average Iraqi does
not know them yet; 3) because the free press does not bother much about Iraq
now that the war drama is over; and 4) because there was - and is - only an
anti-war movement, not a peace movement.
Like
in Bosnia, Kosovo and Afghanistan, the media flock to the wars, not to the
"peace"-building - like vultures feed on carrion. Unfortunately, it
is now the real battle for Iraq and its future is being fought. Unfortunately,
the millions of war protesters stay home now; they do not seem to be able to
get their acts together in a peace movement in solidarity with the Iraqis whose
resources, education, economy, society and leadership is being colonised.
No
matter what the Americans tell the Iraqis and the rest of us, they will run
"liberated" Iraq colonial style. Below you will learn a bit more
about each of the centrally placed personalities. You are right if you wonder
why you have not seen an analysis like this, systematic and with documentation,
in your daily newspaper or on television. You are right if you find it strange
that the media have given you much more (mostly unsubstantiated) information
about 55 top Iraqis, tastelessly depicted on a deck of cards.
Only
the uninformed and the politically naive, only the opportunists and the
imperialists can believe that this has anything whatsoever to do with democracy
or with doing good to the Iraqi people. They have suffered so terribly in their
double cage, the inner cage under Saddam and the outer cage of sanctions, war
and occupation. Every bit of future humanitarian aid, of civilian support and
American NGO activity in Iraq will serve mainly the interests of the Bush
regime and corporate America, not the needs and hopes of the Iraqis.
The
Guardian could state already on April 1 that there was a secret US plan to
set up 23 ministries, all run by Americans.
"The government will take over Iraq
city by city. Areas declared "liberated" by General Tommy Franks will
be transferred to the temporary government under the overall control of Jay Garner,
the former US general appointed to head a military occupation of Iraq.
Decisions on the government's composition
appear to be entirely in US hands, particularly those of Paul Wolfowitz, the
deputy secretary of defence. This has annoyed Gen Garner, who is officially in
charge but who, according to sources close to the planning of the government
has had to accept a number of controversial Iraqis in advisory roles."
This
is how CNN
reported the Bush plan to take over Iraq:
The Bush administration has selected a
U.S. government official to oversee each Iraqi ministry that the U.S. plans to
keep running after the war, CNN has learned. Each official will attempt to keep
his or her ministry running with Iraqi civil servants. Some changes will be
made, though, the sources said:
* The Iraqi Ministry of Information, which controls the
state-run media, will be disbanded and restructured with free television, radio
and print elements
* Sensitive ministries such as those overseeing justice and
intelligence will be overhauled
* The Special Republican Guard and Republican Guard are to be
disbanded, but the plan calls for maintaining the regular army and using its
manpower during reconstruction
The plan also calls for the U.S.
administration team to run a Ministry of Religious Affairs that will oversee
mosques and other religious activities, the sources said.
And
here are some general overviews of the main personalities, one from The Guardian,
one from the Washington
Post and one from National
Journal. A quite comprehensive one has been published by the Sunday Herald.
They are only the beginning. They do not offer the comprehensive background and
necessary links that this essay does.
This
PressInfo
series, updated by May 14, will give you much more, with documentation based on
thousands of searches on the Internet. We have used predominantly Western and
American press sources exactly to show that the materials are available and but
need to be put together. You may ask yourself why it is produced by TFF and not by
multi-million dollar research institutes or leading media of the free press.
Here
is a proposal to someone with money, a heart for the Iraqis and an ability to
get into Iraq. Create a new deck of cards with portraits and descriptions in
Arabic of the Americans who are unlawfully running the independent, sovereign
state of Iraq, a UN member. Distribute it all around Iraq so every Iraq in even
the remotest village will have a precise sense of who his and her new rulers
are. And just let them draw their own conclusions.
The
Americans pay the Iraqis with some prestige and money. At the moment, they
promise people US$ 20 a month to work for them. Imagine how attractive that is
in a country where teachers used to have US$ 3-5 a month. The Americans will
undoubtedly get some things going and we can be certain that the first McDonald
and Burger King will soon open in Baghdad. Quite a few Iraqis may like that what
they see. But the basic point is that the freedom the Iraqis have to
reconstruct and develop Iraq against the will of the Bush regime is not a bit
bigger than the freedom they had to do something against the will of Saddam.
Coalition
partner governments and the rest of us belonging to the West should be deeply
concerned - if not ashamed of what is being done to Iraq. It's the contemporary
version of a 300-year old colonial tradition. We seem to have learnt nothing.
May it soon be brought to an end, for instance through a mass-based, nonviolent
uprising all over Iraq that would send the people you'll meet in this essay
running.
By
mid-May it was announced that some of the people portrayed below were
"re-assigned," "called back" or simply leaving, among them
Jay Garner, the top man. That the US occupation of Iraq came off as a disaster
even before it really took off is beyond doubt. The Times of London muses that
Garner "surrenders
control of Baghdad in a bloodless coup in the fastest regime change in Iraqi
history..."
DONALD
RUMSFELD, PAUL WOLFOWITZ & RICHARD PERLE
Secretaries.
Ideologists
with their own Special Plans. Masters of a war meaning peace and other
"Newspeak"
With
the illegal war on and occupation of Iraq, the first two personalities need no
further introduction. They are Secretary of Defense,
Donald Rumsfeld and Deputy
Secretary of Defence, Paul Wolfowitz.
Then
there one of the leading architects of the whole Iraq imbroglio, "The
Prince of Darkness", Richard Perle
of the American Enterprise Institute and of
the Defense
Policy Board. It's objective is to "serve the public interest by
providing the Secretary of Defense, Deputy Secretary and Under Secretary for
Policy with independent, informed advice and opinion concerning major matters
of defense policy. Nine members of the
Board have ties to defense contractors. Further, Perle is well-connected to
the international media world through Hollinger Digital Inc., the media
management and investment arm of Hollinger International
Inc. whose online newspapers and holdings include The Daily Telegraph in
London and Jerusalem Post. Perle is also former director of the latter. He is
on the board of Onset
Technology, the world's leading provider of message conversion technology
also with close ties to Israeli companies and investment funds. Here is a more personal interview with
Perle about his background and beliefs. Perle is on the advisory board of JINSA,
the Jewish Institute for National Security Affairs. Los Angeles Times
recently revealed more about Perle's combined political and business interests.
There
is so much about them on the Internet. The most recent - and best - related to
the Iraq problematic is Seymour Hersh' Selective Intelligence from The New Yorker of May
2003. Hersh analyses "the Cabal - a small cluster of policy advisers
and analysts now based in the Pentagon's Office of Special Plans. In the past
year, according to former and present Bush Administration officials, their
operation, which was conceived by Paul Wolfowitz, the Deputy Secretary of
Defense, has brought about a crucial change of direction in the American
intelligence community. These advisers and analysts, who began their work in
the days after September 11, 2001, have produced a skein of intelligence
reviews that have helped to shape public opinion and American policy toward
Iraq." In addition, it discusses the pivotal influence of the political
philosopher Leo Strauss on the Cabal and on the director of the Special Plans
operation, Abram Shulsky who happens to be a scholarly expert on Strauss.
You
may acquaint yourself with the real policy makers and Iraq pundits in a more
humorous manner in Slate.
White
House special envoy for both Afghanistan and Iraq
Tremendously
important behind the scenes operator
President
Bush announced on December 2 the appointment of Dr. Zalmay Khalilzad as his
Special Envoy and Ambassador at Large for Free Iraqis. As Special Envoy, Dr.
Khalilzad will serve as the focal point for contacts and coordination among
Free Iraqis for the United States Government and for preparations for a
post-Saddam Hussein Iraq, White House Press Secretary Ari Fleischer said in a
statement.
"Dr. Khalilzad will continue as the
Special Presidential Envoy for Afghanistan to ensure that the United States'
commitment to working in partnership with the Afghan Government remains firm
and resolute. Dr. Khalilzad also serves as Special Assistant to the President
and Senior Director for Southwest Asia, Near East and North African Affairs,
National Security Council. Dr. Khalilzad will relinquish this position so as to
devote full time to Afghanistan, Free Iraqis, and outreach to the Muslim
community. Dr. Khalilzad will continue to serve as Special Assistant to the President
and Senior Director for these matters," the press secretary's statement
said."
Here
follows a presentation of Kalilzad that shows his position in the Cheney-Rumsfeld-RAND
Corporation circles:
"Dr. Khalilzad headed the
Bush-Cheney Transition team for the Department of Defense and has been a
Counselor to Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld. Between 1993 and 1999, Dr.
Khalilzad was Director of the Strategy, Doctrine and Force Structure program
for RAND's Project Air Force. While with RAND, he founded the Center for Middle
Eastern Studies. Between 1991 and 1992, Dr. Khalilzad served as Assistant Under
Secretary of Defense for Policy Planning. He also served as a senior political
scientist at RAND and an associate professor at the University of California at
San Diego in 1989 and 1991. From 1985 to 1989 at the Department of State, Dr.
Khalilzad served as Special Advisor to the Under Secretary of State for
Political Affairs, advising on the Iran-Iraq War and the Soviet War in
Afghanistan. From 1979 to 1989, Dr. Khalilzad was an Assistant Professor of
Political Science at Columbia University. Dr. Khalilzad holds a Ph.D. from the
University of Chicago (1979).”
National
Journal says that Khalilzad is a charter member of the neoconservative
group that has been pushing for the overthrow of Saddam Hussein. With Paul
Wolfowitz he co-wrote the 1997 Weekly Standard article "Overthrow
Him" that was the rallying cry for the bring-down-Saddam cause and an
early blueprint for the Bush doctrine of pre-emption. As a Pentagon aide to
Wolfowitz during the administration of George H.W. Bush, Khalilzad was among
those pushing for a march to Baghdad during the first Persian Gulf War. In
1988, in the final months of the Reagan administration, Khalilzad had urged
Secretary of State George Shultz to explore rapprochement with Iran as a way to
counter the growing influence of Iraq. Shultz, with memories of the Iran-Contra
scandal still fresh, rejected the idea, but it caught on and was pursued with
zeal by the Clinton administration.
In
The Wall Street Journal, he called for NATO expansion, a go-slow approach to
independence for East Timor, and the arming of rebel forces in Kosovo...
According
to CorpWatch,
Zalmay Kalalzad has a long-standing experience with Islamic fundamentalists in
Afghanistan and elsewhere, a good understanding of the region and of the
importance of the oil industry:
CorpWatch
writes:
"Khalilzad became an American
citizen, while serving as a key link between US imperialism and the Islamic fundamentalist
mujahedin fighting the Soviet-backed regime in Kabul -- the milieu out of which
both the Taliban and bin Laden's Al Qaeda group arose. He was a special advisor
to the State Department during the Reagan administration, lobbying successfully
for accelerated US military aid to the mujahedin, including hand-held Stinger
anti-aircraft missiles which played a key role in the war. He later became
undersecretary of defense in the administration of Bush's father, during the US
war against Iraq, then went to the Rand Corporation, a top US military think
tank.
After Bush was installed as president by
a 5-4 vote of the US Supreme Court, Khalilzad headed the Bush-Cheney transition
team for the Defense Department and advised incoming Defense Secretary Donald
Rumsfeld. Significantly, however, he was not named to a subcabinet position,
which would have required Senate confirmation and might have provoked
uncomfortable questions about his role as an oil company advisor in Central
Asia and intermediary with the Taliban. Instead, he was named to the National
Security Council, where no confirmation vote was needed.
At the NSC Khalilzad reports to
Condoleeza Rice, the national security advisor, who also served as an oil
company consultant on Central Asia."
Here
he gives a Breakfast Interview with David
Frost, BBC and here is another
portrait of Kalilzad. He is not a man afraid of making bold promises way
beyond his control. The Anadolu
Agency ran this report on March 20:
Khalilzad: War Will Last Short And
Nothing Will Happen To Civilians; Anadolu Agency: 3/20/2003
Recalling that the U.S. attack against
Iraq started, Khalilzad said that the war would last short and nothing would
happen to civilian people. He added that they would also exert every kind of
efforts for Iraqi people after the war.
Here
is another example from timesunion.com.
When the first meeting of various Iraqi groups, invited by the US, was held
"in the tent" at Ur on April 15, this is what Associated Press
reported Kalilzad to have said:
"The first step toward creating a
postwar government took place under a white-and-gold tent at Ur, the biblical
birthplace of the patriarch Abraham and the cradle of civilization itself.
Participants included Kurds and Sunni and
Shiite Arabs from inside Iraq and others who spent years in exile. U.S.
officials invited the groups, which picked their own representatives. White
House envoy Zalmay Khalilzad assured the delegates that the United States has
"no interest, absolutely no interest, in ruling Iraq. We want you to
establish your own democratic system based on Iraqi traditions and
values," Khalilzad said."
Ambassador,
Presidential Envoy and Senior Coalition Official
Ex-Kissinger
Associates, hawkish anti-terrorist and risk management expert, adviser to US
Homeland Security
On
May 1 it was announced that Paul
Bremer III had been appointed as Presidential
Envoy to Iraq and Senior Coalition Official to Iraq. This is how CNN
reports the relations
between Bremer and the rest:
The man who is currently in charge of
overseeing Iraq's rebuilding, retired U.S. Army Lt. Gen. Jay Garner, reports to
Franks. But White House officials say Garner will at some point report to
Bremer. The two men will work together as issues dictate, the sources said.
Bremer will likely focus on political issues,
including overseeing the emergence of a provisional authority in Baghdad, while
Garner will be concerned with restoring services and civil authority, Pentagon
and administration officials said.
The provisional authority essentially is
the "face of the U.S. government" in Iraq, Pentagon sources said.
This
is how ambassador Bremer is presented by the US National Commission on
Terrorism of which he served as chairman. Paul Bremer III has been Managing
Director of Kissinger Associates. During a 23-year career in the American
diplomatic service, Ambassador Bremer served in Asia, Africa, Europe and
Washington, D.C. He was Ambassador to the Netherlands from 1983 to 1986. From
1986-1989, he served as Ambassador-at-Large for Counter-Terrorism, where he was
responsible for developing and implementing America's global polices to combat
terrorism. Bremer has most recently served as an adviser to Bush on the Homeland
Security Advisory Council. He also serves as Chief Executive Officer of the
Crisis Consulting
Practice of Marsh Inc. a risk management firm. From Republicons.org
we can learn that he shares many views with Perle and Wolfowitz and has
staunchly anti-Iran attitudes.
In
this capacity Bremer addressed the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence in
June 2000. He said 'Iran is still the most egregious state-sponsor of
terrorism, despite the election of a reformist president. The Commission is
concerned that recent American gestures toward Iran could be misinterpreted as
a weakening of our resolve to counter Iranian terrorism.'
The
New
York Times presents Ambassador Bremer in this, not all that friendly,
manner.
But Mr. Bremer's appointment has raised
concerns among some human rights advocates. As chairman of the Congressionally
appointed National Commission on Terrorism in 2000, Mr. Bremer advocated
dropping Central Intelligence Agency guidelines restricting the recruitment of
sources with records of human rights abuses, over the protests of human rights
groups. "His willingness to strike a deal with an abusive figure could be
problematic in Iraq, if he takes a similar approach," said Kenneth Roth,
executive director of Human Rights Watch.
Some Congressional Democrats have also
questioned whether Mr. Bremer, a 61-year-old who has not been involved in a
major reconstruction project before, has the proper experience and personality
to lead the endeavor in a country as large and complex as Iraq.
If
you want to know about the hawkish views
Ambassador Bremer has about terrorism and the Arab world, see his article
on what President Clinton should do if he was serious about the problem,
published in Wall Street Journal in August 1996. Countries with alleged or
documented relations with terrorism must expect to be smashed. Here is one
"if our country gets any indication of Iranian involvement in terrorism
against Americans anywhere, Iran can expect to receive the full weight of
American might. The Joint Chiefs of Staff are to update target lists within
Iran".
Bremer
has edited books on the terrorist challenge; here is the report
from the National Commission on Terrorism and he is co-author of a Heritage
Foundation study on Defending
the American Homeland (2002).
Ambassador
Bremer reports to Donald Rumsfeld, not to Colin Powell. His deputy will be
John Sawers, British ambassador to Cairo, who has been appointed as Britain's
special representative to Iraq.
We
have not been able to find evidence that he has any particular qualifications
or experience in post-war civilian reconstruction, socio-political and economic
development, nation-building or reconciliation.
Commander,
US Central Commend
The
de facto defence minister of Iraq, "Raw country boy and college
dropout" facing allegations. Not a man of many words - or empathy.
Here
is the official bio of
General Tommy Franks who has led the war and who entered Baghdad for the
first time on April 16. This is what
Newsweek wrote about him: "A college dropout, Franks can seem like a
raw country boy. But he has won his stars - as well as his command of the most
powerful military force in the world - by combining a sharp eye with a strong
will." Unfortunately, during the Iraq war he was unable to express
sympathy for the death of fellow coalition soldiers, Iraqi soldiers or
civilians - as a decent soldier should [Go
here and scroll down to Article 34].
As
recently as February 2003, Franks faced "several
allegations" according to CNN:
"Sources have told CNN that Franks,
the man who would lead U.S. forces in the event of a military strike on Iraq,
faces several allegations -- including one that he allowed his wife, Cathy, to
be present during discussions of highly classified material."
Generally,
little is known
about Franks' background but he revealed parts of his personal beliefs to Esquire
in 2002 and here is what CBC has about
him. Franks has two deputies, Michael DeLong and John Abizaid.
Point 1 in the US Central
Command's strategic goals is formulated here: Protect, promote and preserve
U.S. interests in the Central Region to include the free flow of energy
resources, access to regional states, freedom of navigation, and maintenance of
regional stability.
Financial
coordinator for Iraq
The
man chosen to control Iraq's oil revenue, manager of Iraq's central Bank.
Former USAID, Deputy Treasury Secretary and, you guessed it, energy adviser...
Former
U.S. Deputy Treasury Secretary Peter McPherson has been named financial
coordinator for Iraqi reconstruction, Treasury Secretary John Snow has
announced. In an April 25 news release, Snow said that McPherson will serve as
the principal financial and economic policy advisor to Jay Garner, chief of the
U.S. Office of Reconstruction and Humanitarian Assistance (ORHA) in Iraq.
McPherson's background includes service as administrator of the U.S. Agency for
International Development (USAID) from 1981 to 1987. He is currently president
of Michigan State University. In a separate announcement, Snow said that
Treasury Deputy General Counsel George Wolfe will serve as the deputy financial
coordinator of the Iraq reconstruction office. The two officials and will work
closely with Iraqis to assist in rebuilding the finance ministry, the central
bank and the banking system in Iraq, Treasury said.
Here
is the bio
of McPherson. Like most other info on the net it does not mention that McPherson is also Chair of the
Secretary of Energy Advisory Board for the US Department of Energy. With an
expertise in both finance matters and energy, Pherson must be uniquely
competent.
And,
so, he is. He is the man centrally placed in the US draft resolution to the UN.
Here is Column Lynch's report for the Washington Post Service of May 9:
Under the system proposed by the
administration, the proceeds of Iraq's oil revenues would be placed in an Iraqi
Assistance Fund held by the Central Bank of Iraq, which is being managed by
Peter McPherson, a former deputy treasury secretary and Bank of America
executive.
The United States and its allies would
have the sole power to spend the money on relief, reconstruction and
disarmament operations and to pay ''for other purposes benefiting the people of
Iraq.'' The ''funds in the Iraqi Assistance Fund shall be disbursed at the
direction of the [U.S.-led coalition], in consultation with the Iraqi Interim
Authority,'' the resolution states.
He
is a friend of vice-president Cheney, according to the Washington
Post. We have not been able to find evidence that he has any particular
qualifications or experience in post-war civilian reconstruction,
socio-political and economic development, nation-building or reconciliation.
ORHA,
the Office of Reconstruction and Humanitarian Assistance
L.
Paul Bremer and General Jay Garner and a team of some 300 retired military men,
diplomats and functionaries from numerous government agencies have been
"recruited" or "appointed" by the Bush administration and,
especially, by the Pentagon to administer postwar Iraq through the Office
of Reconstruction and Humanitarian Assistance that comes under Pentagon.
Here are the backgrounds and profiles about some of them. Interestingly, there
are very few questions asked in the free press about this completely undemocratic,
ambiguous method to take over a country and shape its future.
Governor
- Co-ordinator
Retired
US general, pro-Israel from the defence industry, with a past job in Northern
Iraq, supposed to be the highest authority
Sometimes
called the new "viceroy" of Iraq, Retired Lieutenant
General Jay Garner is the man in charge of the Office of Reconstruction and
Humanitarian Assistance.
Here
is how the New York Times presents Jay Garner. And here follows a critical background
from The Guardian:
"There is no argument among Arab
opinion formers, who with rare unanimity have been condemning his appointment
as another sign of American contempt for Iraqi feelings,"
"One is the general's work since
retiring from the army as president of defence contractor SY Coleman, now part
of a communications-led outfit called L3. An L3 spokesman insisted that Gen
Garner's firm does not make military hardware but specialises in the guidance
systems. In other words, he is the man who has been trying to make sure the
weapons hit the targets rather than the surrounding civilians. This may be
true, but this might require an over-subtle explanation in the Baghdad souks if
Iraqis start to believe they are being ruled by a man who was just trying to
kill them."
And
here is a sympathetic
portrait of Garner, the DeSoto native who will lead the transformation of
faraway Iraq, from HeraldTribune.com. The Sydney
Morning Herald paints a rather skeptical portrait of Garner from the
perspective of "the critical glare of Arab eyes."
However,
here is a thorough documentation of Jay Garner's past and relations - by human
rights people who have set up a whole website "StopJayGarner.com". Another, Pacific
News Service, provides an analysis
that is also pretty devastating for Garner in his role as future civilian
governor of Iraq.
What
we learn from the materials on these sites is that Garner has been involved
with the weapons manufacturing company SY Coleman, with the Patriot
Missile system, and with the Star Wars project. He has been director of the
Provide Comfort Program, the operation that coordinated humanitarian help in
Iraqi's Kurdish territory at the end of Gulf War I. Assigned to that position
by then Secretary of Defense, Dick Cheney, Garner oversaw an office that was
created by a U.N. mandate. Now he is appointed by the Pentagon
(Rumsfeld/Wolfowitz) to rebuild and run Iraq.
Garner
has been associated with The Jewish Institute for National Security Affairs, JINSA, and participated in its
JINSA October 2000 Statement. This statement is explained
by JINSA here. It has remarkable formulations praising Israel's remarkable
restraint and denouncing the Palestinians with generalising formulations such
as, "We are appalled by the Palestinian political and military leadership
that teaches children the mechanics of war while filling their heads with
hate."
Given
that Israel is seen as the security problem par excellence by Iraqis, it will
be interesting to see whether General Garner will be able to build confidence
with any Iraqi who knows where his basic loyalties lie.
It
will also be interesting to see whether he has a chance to win the hearts and
minds of the Iraqis. Upon his first visit to Baghdad on April 21, BBC reported:
Iraq's main Shia groups are boycotting
talks with Mr. Garner
The retired US general sent to lead an
interim administration has begun assessing the damage the war inflicted on
Baghdad, where large parts of the population are still without water or
electricity.
Jay Garner flew into Baghdad insisting he
was a "facilitator not a ruler", but opposition appeared to be growing
to the invading forces taking a leading role in the reconstruction.
A Kurdish leader, Jalal Talabani, said he
objected to any "foreigner" leading an administration for Iraq.
Groups representing the majority Shia
Muslim population have already said they will not co-operate with a US
administration and are boycotting talks led by Mr. Garner.
In
addition, his appointment - and that of all the other people with military
backgrounds - raises the issue of militarised civilian reconstruction. It has
already drawn criticism from many and different experts, e.g. Sara Kenyon
Lischer in the Christian
Science Monitor of April 15 and Larry Thompson of Refugees International on
Reuters
AlertNet April 9, 2003.
Garner,
to be sure, has set up ORHA
in a 258-room Republican Palace on the banks of the Tigris River. But he is
not going to enjoy that for any long time. It is expected that he will be
replaced by Bremer by mid-May.
Garner's
chief of staff
Retired
lieutenant general and top guy of US mercenary-consultancy firm, MPRI
Like
many others, Bates
served in Vietnam and has had all kinds of military assignments and received
many medals. Here is his relations
to MPRI. Here is a short, critical
description of MPRI:
Insiders joke that MPRI has more generals
than the Pentagon. This high level mercenary group has over 1000 elite military
and law enforcement leaders on retainer, including Gen. Ed Soyster, former head
of the Defense Intelligence Agency, Gen. Frederick Kroesen, former commander of
the U.S. Army in Europe and a former Assistant Director of the FBI Many of its
employees serve on the Council of Foreign Relations. The President, Carl Vuono
was the Army Chief of Staff during the invasion of Panama and the Gulf War. He
retired after the war and joined MPRI in 1991. One of his first big jobs was
advising the Croatian government when it split away from Yugoslavia. He is
credited with the victorious military strategy of lightning armor drives that
were used against the Serbs. MPRI is a military consultancy and also supplies
pilots and Special Forces and elite training and security services worldwide.
They recently completed an $800,000 contract to review and advise the Colombian
military. MPRI also runs the US Army's college program, the ROTC, at over 200 US
universities.
And
here is the MPRI website. Garner
and Bates worked for subsidiaries of the same defence contractor, L-3
Communications Systems.
We
have not been able to find evidence that he has any particular qualifications
or experience in post-war civilian reconstruction, socio-political and economic
development, nation-building or reconciliation.
Top
adviser to Garner
Rumsfeld's
senior aide in Iraq, US Navy, worked for Republican senators and the
conservative Heritage Foundation
Just
below J. Garner, who reports to T. Franks, is a line to Larry DiRita, who is
a special assistant to the defense chief. He is Rumsfeld's senior aide and a
Naval Academy graduate. Larry Di Rita joined the Department of Defense after
serving as Legislative Director, then Chief of Staff, for U.S. Senator Kay
Bailey Hutchison [R-Texas] from 1996 until 2001. Prior to that, he served as
Policy Director to the 1996 Presidential campaign of U.S. Senator Phil Gramm.
Previously, he served at the Heritage Foundation as Deputy Director of Foreign
Policy and Defense Studies. DiRita is a veteran of the U.S. Navy. His final
tour was on the Joint Staff under General Colin Powell. He is a graduate of the
United States Naval Academy, and he has a Master's Degree from the Johns
Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies.
We
have not been able to find evidence that he has any particular qualifications
or experience in post-war civilian reconstruction, socio-political and economic
development, nation-building or reconciliation.
Deputy
director of ORHA
Former
SFOR commander in Bosnia and Croatia, consultant for many companies
Retired General Adams
served in a wide variety of command and staff positions in Vietnam; Korea; around
the Pacific Rim; in the Middle East and in Europe, including service as
Commander of the NATO led thirty-four nation Stabilization Force, SFOR, in
Bosnia-Herzegovina and Croatia. Although much of his service was outside the
continental United States, General Adams also served on the Army General Staff,
the Army Secretariat and the Joint Staff, during multiple tours of duty in the
Pentagon.
Since
leaving active duty, General Adams has worked as a consultant for a number of
large companies and serves on several advisory boards for non-profit
organizations, a private foundation and a public university.
We
have not been able to find what companies Ron Adams has served. We have not
been able to find evidence that he has any particular qualifications or experience
in post-war civilian reconstruction, socio-political and economic development,
nation-building or reconciliation.
BARBARA
BODINE
Co-ordinator
of Central Iraq
A
past in Iraq and Kuwait, controversial, an exception by being close to State
Department - and suddenly leaving
To
be based in Baghdad. Barbara Bodine,
the former US ambassador to Yemen who served in Baghdad in the 1980s, will look
after the central region, including Baghdad. Ms Bodine was held
hostage at the US embassy in Kuwait during the 1991 Gulf War. She is
reportedly one of a group of State Department Arabists who made it on to the
team after the Pentagon rejected a number of former US ambassadors and
diplomats. There seems to have been quite some controversy about her ways of
handling the investigation following the attack on USS Cole
in the Port of Aden which happened in October 2000 when she was US ambassador
to Yemen. Bodine
has worked for former Republican presidential candidate Bob Dole and former
Republican secretary of state Henry Kissinger, and served under presidents
Ronald Reagan and George Bush Sr. Here is an official CV. And
here is a recent critical
comment about her from the Washington Post.
On
May 11 and 12, VOA announced that Brodine
has resigned or, rather, abruptly
called back to Washington.
Co-ordinator
of Southern Iraq
Retired
general, Texas businessman, with a past, like many others, in Vietnam
Another
retired general and Texas businessman, will oversee the south. He is one more
in the group who has been hand-picked by the Pentagon. This is what CBC News has to tell
about him:
His territory will extend from the
borders with Saudi Arabia and Kuwait to just north of Karbala. The team will
eventually set up camp in Basra after the fighting subsides. Walters retired
from the army after serving for 32 years. Since then, he has worked for an
insurance company in Texas and told the Washington Times that he plans to be
back at his desk job in less than a year. He told the paper he never considered
turning down the job. "I served my country for 32 years, and I would not
like to think about sitting on my porch having said no. This is a time of
history, and I want to be here," he said.
In
1966, General
Walters served in Vietnam in Project Delta and in
command of a Special Forces camp.
Returning to Vietnam in 1969, General Walters served as a Battalion S3
and later as Deputy G1 in the 101st Airborne Division.
We
have not been able to find evidence that he has any particular qualifications
or experience in post-war civilian reconstruction, socio-political and economic
development, nation-building or reconciliation.
Co-ordinator
of Northern Iraq
Retired
army general with ties to US mercenary-consultancy company MPRI
Retired
army major general, Bruce Moore, has been appointed coordinator for Northern
Iraq with his base in Mosul. This is how Fox News presents his background:
Prior to his appointment to ORHA, Moore served
at PAE Government Services, Inc. as consultant on a joint Department of State
and Department of Defense initiative to solicit the support of the countries of
Mauritania, Mali, Sudan and Chad in the War on Terrorism.
At MPRI, in Alexandria, VA General Moore
served from 2000-2001 as a Program Manager for Military Stabilization Program
for Bosnia-Herzegovina, a multi-million dollar program that assisted the
Bosnian Government in establishing a NATO compatible Ministry of Defense and
Armed Forces. Moore also directed the Nigeria Assessment, an in depth
assessment of the actions required to insure a successful transition from a
military government to a civilian government.
PAE has grown from designing
bridges to installing offshore oil platforms to supplying entire labor forces
to maintaining extensive military installations and bases. And MPRI, Military Professional Resources, Inc., is
one of those para-military, private mercenary companies that also, for
instance, "stabilised" Macedonia in 2002.
We
have not been able to find evidence that he has any particular qualifications
or experience in post-war civilian reconstruction, socio-political and economic
development, nation-building or reconciliation.
Co-ordinator
for reconstruction and USAID director of Iraq
Relevant
education and broad international experience in development matters
A
Senior Foreign Service Officer, Lucke has served for 24 years at the U.S.
Agency for International Development ((USAID) in seven overseas posts. He
served as USAID Mission Director in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, from 2000-2001,
where he managed the largest U.S. development program in the Western
Hemisphere. More
about him here. He is also the US AID Mission director
in Iraq. He has a degree in international studies, have worked in development programmes
in many countries and is, thus, one of the few whose background, education and
experience may be relevant to the Iraqis.
Co-ordinator
for humanitarian assistance
Marine
Corps and State Department man, experience from Germany unification and with
Kosovo-Albanians
Until
George F. Ward,
Jr. was appointed to go to Iraq, he directed the US Institute for Peace's
Training Program. He joined the Institute in 1999 after a thirty-year career in
the Foreign Service, which concluded with his appointment as United States
ambassador to the Republic of Namibia in 1996-99. In Namibia, he managed a
successful humanitarian de-mining program and initiated a campaign against
gender violence. As principal deputy assistant secretary of state for
international organization affairs in 1992-96, he helped formulate United
States policy on multilateral peacekeeping and managed the policy process on
United Nations political questions.
During
his assignment as deputy chief of mission in Germany in 1989-92, Ward played a
leading role in the negotiations that led to German unification. He received
the State Department's Distinguished Honor Award for his service in Germany.
During earlier Foreign Service assignments in Germany, Italy, and Washington,
he worked extensively on European security questions. Prior to his Foreign
Service career, Ward was an officer in the United States Marine Corps, serving
in the United States and Vietnam. He holds a B.A. in history from the
University of Rochester and an M.P.A. with a concentration in systems analysis
from Harvard University.
Here
is one more who has a background in the Marine Corps, but belongs to the
minority who comes from the State Department and has a relevant education and
working experience. In September 1999, in the aftermath of NATO's bombing of
Yugoslavia, he
helped various groups of Kosovo-Albanians agree on co-operation toward
democracy.
Deputy
to Jay Garner
A
British exception with an interest in Christian ethics