FREE hit counter and Internet traffic statistics from
(DV) Frank: The Minuteman Project







The Minuteman Project:
Gunning for Change but Shooting Blanks

by Joshua Frank
April 5, 2005

Send this page to a friend! (click here)


In an online recruiting effort that would impress Joe Trippi, approximately 500 well- armed individuals known as The Minutemen have come together in hopes they can guard the vast expanse of the US-Mexican border out in Arizona. Their mission: Deter illegal immigrants and protect these great United States of America.

Taking their name from the hand-picked forces from the 17th and 18th Century American militias that were selected “to fight at a minute's notice” -- the 21st century Minutemen come from all over the US, and have congregated in Arizona where they plan to act out their wildest Wyatt Earp fantasies. With their shotguns and egos fully loaded, the militia has set up camps up and down the border in Cochise County, Arizona, the supposed epicenter of illegal immigration into the United States.

“People have this impression we [are] a paramilitary group coming here to stir up trouble. It's so hard to convince them that ... we're peaceful,” Joel Segal, a young member of the Minutemen told the Arizona Republic. “Obviously, we're armed, but that's just a part of us being out here. That doesn't mean that we're aggressive. That doesn't mean that we're violent.”

Yeah right. Then what the hell are the guns for? Gopher hunting? It's not that they don't have a right to patrol the US border, or pack a loaded weapon. Sure they do have those rights. But do the Minutemen really think Mexicans sneaking across the border are looking for another Alamo? No, scratch that. Forget I even asked.

Doubtful the Minutemen are capable of peering below the surface of the complex issue of US immigration. Like, say, what is it that the US government is doing to Mexico that may be increasing non-legal immigration? One answer: NAFTA.

If it is their own jobs they are so worried about, the Minutemen are patrolling the wrong borders. Non-legals by and large are employed in the darker sectors of the US economy -- ones most Americans aren't willing to take part in.

All a skeptic need do is drive through the fruit fields of California, take a peak into the sweatshops in New York City, or visit a bloody slaughterhouse out in Greeley, Colorado, to catch a glimpse of the grand Mexican life in the USA.

No, the real threat to American jobs isn't illegal immigrants. It's the outsourcing of entire industries to places like India that have shoved a knife in the back of the US worker.

The Minutemen may also be surprised to learn the following: According to the US Census administered in 2000, there are approximately 8,705,419 non-legal foreign-born persons living in the US. Of that number, 4,787,980 were from countries other than Mexico. In fact, almost 40% of all US immigrants were not even Hispanic. [1]

Well over 1.2 million were from Asian countries, with another 1.1 million flying in

from European lands -- not to mention the hundreds of thousands who have come in from Africa and the Middle East. The majority of these immigrants didn't cross the Mexican border -- they flew over on airplanes.

“The message is, if you have enough manpower at the border, you can stop illegals from coming across,” Cathy Cushman of the Minutemen Project told the San Gabriel Valley Tribune.

No question Cathy and her pals have their work cut out for them. Even so, I'd love to see the nutty Minutemen haul their arsenal and set up camp in the JFK airport.

Okay, you're right. Let's not give them any ideas.

Joshua Frank is the author of the forthcoming book, Left Out! How Liberals Helped Reelect George W. Bush, to be published by Common Courage Press. You can pre-order a copy at discounted rate at: Josh can be reached at:


[1] Note: this number includes “people who are here legally but are not yet included in the official estimates of legal migrants and refugees. It also includes people in ‘quasi-legal’ status who are awaiting action on their legal migration requests.”

Other Recent Articles by Josh Frank

* US Intelligence “Dead Wrong”: Skeptics Were Right All Along
* The Selling-Out of the Antiwar Movement, Part Two
* The Selling-Out of the Antiwar Movement, Part One
* Hope in Red State America: Lessons from the Big Sky Country (Part 2)
* A Red State Paradox (Part One): Montana on the Cusp
* Protecting Campaign Coffers, Not Nature: The Trials of Max Baucus
* Diagnosing the Green Party: Narcissism Runs Rampant
* Farewell Hope: The Hogtying of the Deaniacs
* It Just Takes One McVeigh to Ruin Your Day
* The Distortions of Acumen Continued: More Liberal Trashing of Ward Churchill
* The Distortions of Acumen: Liberals Trash Ward Churchill
* Howard Dean’s Been Suckered: The Establishment Corrals the Deaniacs
* Democrats Support Bush’s Iran Policy
* Hope is Not on the Way: The Farce of the DNC Contest
* Privacy Piracy? What Howard Dean May Bring to the DNC
* Voter Fraud as Fundraiser: David Cobb and the Ohio Recount
* How the New York Times Misreports: An Interview with Howard Friel
* Liberalism and Its Bounds
* The Reelection of George W. Bush: A Possible Bright Side?
* Blame Kerry’s Loss on the ABB Crowd: An Interview with Kevin Zeese
* Face the Music: Time to Oppose Our Troops’ Actions
* Democrats Commit Suicide
* The Dems Should be Ashamed: Bush With a TKO
* For Kerry, It’s Not Easy Pretending to be Green
* Shooting From the Hip: Kerry Out-Guns Bush
* The Democrats’ Own Weapons of Mass Deception
* David Cobb, the Greens and the Sinking of the Left
* Interview with Green Party Presidential Candidate David Cobb
* Fear Mongering 101: Progressives Hit the Road for Kerry
* Swing-Along-With-Ralph: Nader in the Battleground States
* Bombs Ahoy: Iraq, From Clinton to Bush
* Too Many Cameras and Not Enough Truth: John Kerry Dodges the Press
* The Green Party Unravels From Within
* The Florida of the Northwest: Oregon Democrats Sabotage Nader...Again
* Partisan Protests: Not All of New York Rises Up
* Greens at the Crossroads: Party Fights for its Future
* Ralph Nader as David Duke? The ADL Wants You to Think So
* Monkeywrench Hope: An Interview with Jeffrey St. Clair
* Why the 2004 Election Pretty Much Sucks